Pending home sales fell to a level no one has seen in the history of the series. The National Association of Realtors said on Wednesday, November 18 that contract signings for previously owned homes fell 4.7 percent in October and fell 16.7 percent from a year earlier. The Pending Home Sales Index dropped to 63.0, the lowest reading since the series began in 2001. Forecasters expected a fall of only 2.0 percent. After twenty years as a Florida real estate broker, I read a second straight record low as a freeze, not a normal slowdown.
Pending Home Sales Numbers for October
September set the first record low when the index fell to 66.0, and our coverage of that release in Pending Home Sales Hit Record Low in September explained why signings lead the market. October has now gone lower. An index of 100 equals the average level of contract activity in 2001, so 63.0 means signings ran at a little under two thirds of that baseline pace.
Every region fell in the month and from a year earlier. The Northeast fell 0.8 percent in the month and 11.1 percent from a year earlier. The Midwest fell 2.7 percent and 14.0 percent. The South fell 6.3 percent and 18.7 percent. The West fell 6.9 percent and 20.3 percent. Even the strongest large metro areas fell, with Cincinnati down 4.7 percent, Austin down 9.7 percent and Jacksonville in Florida down 12.8 percent on the list of smallest declines.
Pending contracts matter because a sale counts as pending when the contract is signed but the sale has not yet closed, and most close within one or two months. Lawrence Yun, chief economist at the National Association of Realtors, said two consecutive months of record low pending contracts point to very sluggish closings in the fourth quarter, and annual existing home sales could be the lowest since the middle of the 1990s. That lands on top of the October closings report last week, which already showed existing home sales at their slowest pace since 2010.
Why Buyers Froze in October
The cause is the monthly payment. Mortgage rates surged into October, with the average 30 year fixed rate reaching 7.40 percent on October 8, the highest since November 2023 according to Realtor.com. Reuters noted the same rate was 7.18 percent last week in Freddie Mac data. Realtor.com estimated that rates climbed by nearly 75 basis points from late August to the middle of October, adding roughly 200 dollars a month to the typical payment on a median priced home for a buyer putting 10 percent down.
Yun said it is somewhat puzzling that home sales would fall to levels last seen three decades ago even as the population has grown by roughly 75 million people. Either a large amount of demand is building in the background while people wait, or the dream of homeownership is moving out of reach for many Americans. Waiting because your payment would strain your budget today is a decision. Waiting because you assume a crash will hand you a bargain later is a guess, and this report gives that guess no support, because prices were not the part that collapsed. Signing volume collapsed.
Our Real Estate Hub keeps these housing releases together with our buyer and seller guides, so you can judge one report against the trend.
Builders Sent a Mixed Signal the Same Morning
A second federal report arrived a few hours earlier, and it explains why relief from new supply will be slow. The Census Bureau said housing starts rose 9.9 percent in October to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 1.309 million, up from a revised 1.191 million in September. Single family starts rose 4.0 percent to 864,000, though they fell 3.2 percent from a year earlier, while larger multifamily projects carried much of the monthly gain.
Permits told the forward looking story, and it pointed down. Total permits fell 7.4 percent in the month and 8.7 percent from a year earlier to 1.295 million, the lowest level since May 2020. Single family permits fell 8.7 percent to 772,000 and fell 12.9 percent from a year earlier. Completions rose 6.5 percent in the month but fell 10.4 percent from a year earlier, with a pace of 1.272 million homes. Builder confidence fell in November to its lowest level since April 2012, and a large share of builders reported cutting prices. When permits fall this hard, future starts and completions usually feel the pressure in the months that follow.
What This Means for Buyers and Sellers
For buyers who can afford the payment at current rates, a freeze cuts both ways. Competition is thin, sellers have shown more willingness to cut prices and negotiate, and homes sit long enough for a careful inspection. The risk is buying a payment that leaves no room for taxes, insurance and repairs, especially in Florida where those ownership costs can change after you close. Run the full monthly cost, not just principal and interest, and keep a cash reserve after closing.
For sellers, this report is a pricing instruction. Buyers are not refusing every home. They are refusing payments that feel out of line with rates near or above 7 percent. A home priced for the market of two years ago can sit while a similar home priced for this market still signs a contract, even in a record low month. Yun also offered one hopeful note, saying October could mark the low point in contract signings for this cycle as mortgage rates appear to have topped out. Treat that as a possibility to watch in the November report, not as a promise.
What to Do With This Report
- If you plan to buy in the next six months, get a full payment quote at a rate above the best rate you hope for, then decide whether the home still works. If it only works at a rate you do not hold, you are not ready for that price.
- If you plan to sell, price from the most recent closed sales in your area and from the payment a buyer will face at current rates, not from the highest asking price on your street.
- If you are waiting, use the wait with purpose. Build the down payment, clean up revolving balances and watch the November report for a real change in direction.
- Ignore anyone who uses a record low headline to rush you. A freeze rewards patience and preparation.
The takeaway is clear. Pending home sales at 63.0 mark the weakest signing pace since the series began in 2001, permits sit at their lowest since May 2020, and the block is the monthly payment at high mortgage rates, not a lack of people who want a home. Decide from your own full cost and timeline, and let the next reports confirm whether October was the low point.
Want a calmer system for big housing and money decisions without chasing every headline? Download our free ebook at Unlocking Financial Freedom and build a written plan you can follow all year.











